Operators in "a handful" of European-member states must give governments direct, permanent access to their networks, a report by UK-based Vodafone has revealed.

It is understood these unnamed countries number six in total, and are able to bypass any control operators have over lawful interception, according to Vodafone’s first ever Law Enforcement Disclosure report.

The news comes amid increasing public discussion about the access governments have to their communications data, particularly following the disclosures of state surveillance by former CIA operative Edward Snowden last year.

Telecoms operators are increasingly concerned about how the public views their role in such matters.

As such, Vodafone said it is governments – not operators – who hold the primary duty to provide greater transparency on the number of agency and authority demands issued to companies such as theirs.

The operator said dealings with state agencies and authorities fall into one of the three categories: mandatory compliance with lawful demands; emergency and non-routine assistance; and protecting Vodafone customers and networks from attack.

It added: “If we receive a demand for assistance which falls outside these three categories, we will challenge it and refuse to comply.”

The report, which Vodafone said had been “very complex and challenging” to compile, encompasses instances where the operator received a lawful demand for assistance in 29 countries between 1 April 2013 and 31 March 2014.

Specifically, it looked at two categories of law enforcement demands that account for the “overwhelming majority” of all such activity: lawful interception and access to communications data.

According to the operator, there is “very little coherence and consistency” in law and agency and authority practice, even between neighbouring EU Member States.

The report stated: “In practice, laws governing agencies’ and authorities’ access to customer data are often both broad and opaque… and frequently lag the development and use of communications technology.”

Adding to the complexity, Vodafone said, is that no individual operator can provide a full picture of the extent of agency and authority demands across a country as a whole.

“Different operators are likely to have widely differing approaches to recording and reporting the same statistical information… the scope for miscounting is immense,” it commented.

In the UK, for example, Section 19 of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 prohibits operators from disclosing the existence of any lawful interception warrant and the existence of any requirement to provide assistance in relation to a warrant.

However, in Spain Vodafone revealed it had received 24,212 demands for lawful interception and 48,679 requests for communications data.

In some countries, such as Germany and Italy, it is government agencies themselves that publish the information regarding lawful interception.

But Vodafone was able to reveal that Italian authorities made 605,601 requests for communications data.

In Ireland, there were 4,124 requests for communications data, but Vodafone was prohibited from revealing the number of lawful interception requests.

Vodafone said: “Inconsistent publication of statistical information by individual operators amounts to an inadequate and unsustainable foundation for true transparency and public insight.”

A full country-by-country breakdown can be found here.

Vodafone admitted that it is possible “to learn a great deal about an individual’s movements, interests and relationships from an analysis of metadata and other data associated with their use of a communications network”.

In response, it said it has developed “strict rules” governing the use of communications data for marketing purposes, for example.

In each of Vodafone’s operating companies around the world, a “small number” of employees are tasked with liaising with agencies and authorities in order to process demands received.

Overall, it said it has to balance its responsibility to respect its customers’ right to privacy against a legal obligation to respond to the authorities’ lawful demands.

Read more

Operators warned to push security up the agenda and respond quicker


More News

Iliad enters content game in France, finally launches Italian mobile business Iliad enters content game in France, finally launches Italian mobile business Iliad has acquired football rights in France and launched its opco in Italy as it looks to reboot after a disappointing set of financial results. More detail
Three UK appoints new CCO, CFO Three UK appoints new CCO, CFO The departure of Three UK's Chief Commercial Officer after just 18 months in the job has triggered a shake-up of the mobile operator's top team. More detail
TalkTalk to sell enterprise customer base to Daisy as it registers full-year loss TalkTalk to sell enterprise customer base to Daisy as it registers full-year loss TalkTalk has agreed to sell 80,000 business customers to rival Daisy Group in a £175 million deal. More detail
A1 Telekom Austria Group rebrand reaches Bulgaria A1 Telekom Austria Group rebrand reaches Bulgaria Bulgaria is the third A1 Telekom Austria Group opco to get rebranded as the telco looks to market itself as a provider of "advanced" IT, IoT, cloud and content services. More detail
Orange Business Services puts IoT to use on saving ships’ fuel costs Orange Business Services puts IoT to use on saving ships’ fuel costs Orange Business Services has expanded its work with Dobroflot by developing a customised IoT solution for the Russian fishing company. More detail


European Communications is now
Mobile Europe and European Communications


From June 2018, European Communications magazine 
has merged with its sister title Mobile Europe, into 
Mobile Europe and European Communications.

No more new content is being published on this site - 

for the latest news and features, please go to: